Skift Take
The European Union’s guideline gives a glance into how the U.S. might implement its automated refunds policy– though there are key differences.
Meghna Maharishi
When the Biden administration announced airlines would be required to immediately refund travelers for considerably delayed or canceled flights, the airline industry claimed there were unanswered concerns.
Are airline companies 100% responsible for refunds, even if a prolonged delay or cancellation is brought on by an air-traffic control problem? What about the weather condition?
American Airlines CEO Robert Isom stated the guideline had some “gray” locations. Airlines for America, the biggest trade group for major U.S. airline companies, took a harsh position and called the rule “anti-competitive.”
And now, automatic refunds are most likely to become a part of U.S. law, after the Senate included a provision for them in its FAA reauthorization costs.
However the European Union passed something similar in 2004, and the guideline entered into result in 2005.
The EU’s experience offers ideas to how it may enter the U.S., though there are likewise essential distinctions.
What Is EU261?
The European Union’s Air Guest Rights Guideline is roughly similar to the DOT’s automated refunds– however it has some differences. In Europe, airline companies should allow travelers to pick in between a refund or being scheduled on an alternative flight.
On top of this, if the disruption was within the airline company’s control, or not an “extraordinary circumstance,” passengers can ask for additional settlement. For instance, travelers flying to and from the EU can get as much as 600 euros, or about $658, for a considerably postponed or canceled flight that is at least 3,500 kilometers, or 2,175 miles under specific situations.
The law, likewise known as EU261, applies to flights within the EU; flights that arrive in the EU that are run by an EU airline; and flights that leave from the EU, operated by an EU or non-EU airline.
For canceled flights, the EU rule permits travelers the choice of a ticket compensation and return flight to the airport of departure for any connecting flights.
John Grant, a chief expert at travel information firm OAG, stated the U.S. was following the EU in executing automatic refunds.
“It levels the playing field a bit, and it also cleans a few of the issues that became visible throughout the pandemic when airlines basically didn’t wish to refund money due to the fact that they didn’t have quite cash themselves,” Grant stated.
When the EU first implemented rule 261, it was met with similar industry pushback, Grant stated.
“Whilst there was concern, I believe the more philosophical airlines stated, ‘Look, we have actually got to pay it,'” he said. “‘It’s not our money. We have actually not concluded the contract as such. We had an agreement to fly the passenger. We didn’t. Therefore, we need to reimburse them.'”
The U.S. Goes a Step More Than the EU
Despite the resemblances, the DOT’s guideline goes a step further. EU261 makes exceptions for “amazing circumstances,” that include air-traffic control concerns, geopolitical instability, bad weather condition and security dangers.
The DOT told Skift that guests would be entitled to an automated refund no matter the reason. The FAA costs also does not include language on whether airlines would be exempt from providing automatic refunds due to serious weather condition or air-traffic control problems.
Blaise Waguespack, a teacher at Embry-Riddle University, said certain scenarios beyond an airline’s control, such as Pratt & Whitney engine recalls, might present issues when it pertains to automated refunds.
“That word ‘automatic’ kind of developed concerns I’ll state, in the airline management suites, because it resembles, ‘Wait up, just how much of this is truly us versus just how much is their issues,'” Waguespack said.
Up until now, the CEOs of American and Frontier both said they didn’t expect the new guideline to affect their airlines’ bottom line. Grant said the new DOT guideline wouldn’t cause greater fares to offset any refunds.
“No, it will not. In time, the market is so increasingly competitive,” Grant said. “It can’t pay for to begin rates in these kinds of things regularly.”
Airlines Sector Stock Index Efficiency Year-to-Date
What am I looking at? The performance of airline sector stocks within the ST200. The index consists of companies publicly traded throughout global markets including network providers, low-cost carriers, and other related business.
The Skift Travel 200 (ST200) combines the financial efficiency of almost 200 travel companies worth more than a trillion dollars into a single number. See more airline companies sector financial performance.
Read the full approach behind the Skift Travel 200.